Searching over 5,500,000 cases.


searching
Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.

O'Brien v. State Compensation Insurance Fund

Court of Workers Compensation of Montana

February 10, 1998

JACK J. O'BRIEN, Petitioner,
v.
STATE COMPENSATION INSURANCE FUND, Respondent/Insurer for PINE HILLS SCHOOL, Employer.,

          Submitted: February 6, 1998

          ORDER GRANTING MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER

          MIKE McCARTER JUDGE

         Summary: Claimant demands sanctions under section 39-71-2914, MCA (1991), against the attorney filing a response on behalf of State Fund which asserted the insurer's claim for "equittable subrogation" in claimant's third-party recovery in a malpractice case. Claimant noticed the deposition of Carl Swanson, President of State Compensation Insurance Fund. State Fund moved to quash the deposition.

         Held: Protective order granted prohibiting deposition. Sanctions under section 39-71-2914, MCA (1991) are available against an attorney signing a pleadings which is not "warranted by existing law or a good faith argument for extension, modification or reversal of existing law." The issue raised is whether State Fund's position, put forth by its counsel, was beyond the pale of legitimate advocacy. Mr. Swanson is not, to the Court's knowledge, an attorney, certainly did not sign the pleading in question, and is beyond the ambit of sanctions.

         Topics:

Constitutions, Statutes, Regulations and Rules: Montana Code Annotated: section 39-71-2914, MCA (1991). Claimant demanded sanctions under section 39-71-2914, MCA (1991), against the attorney filing a response on behalf of State Fund which asserted the insurer's claim for "equittable subrogation" in claimant's third-party recovery in a malpractice case. Claimant noticed the deposition of Carl Swanson, President of State Compensation Insurance Fund. Protective order granted prohibiting deposition. Sanctions under section 39-71-2914, MCA (1991) are available against an attorney signing a pleadings which is not "warranted by existing law or a good faith argument for extension, modification or reversal of existing law." The issue raised is whether State Fund's position, put forth by its counsel, was beyond the pale of legitimate advocacy. Mr. Swanson is not, to the Court's knowledge, an attorney, certainly did not sign the pleading in question, and is beyond the ambit of sanctions.
Discovery: Protective Orders. Claimant demanded sanctions under section 39-71-2914, MCA (1991), against the attorney filing a response on behalf of State Fund which asserted the insurer's claim for "equittable subrogation" in claimant's third-party recovery in a malpractice case. Claimant noticed the deposition of Carl Swanson, President of State Compensation Insurance Fund. Protective order granted prohibiting deposition. Sanctions under section 39-71-2914, MCA (1991) are available against an attorney signing a pleadings which is not "warranted by existing law or a good faith argument for extension, modification or reversal of existing law." The issue raised is whether State Fund's position, put forth by its counsel, was beyond the pale of legitimate advocacy. Mr. Swanson is not, to the Court's knowledge, an attorney, certainly did not sign the pleading in question, and is beyond the ambit of sanctions.

         ¶1 The petitioner/claimant (claimant) in this matter has noticed the deposition of Carl Swanson, President of the State Compensation Insurance Fund (State Fund). The State Fund moved to quash the deposition, which was then postponed to allow the claimant to respond in writing to the motion before the Court issued its ruling. That response has now been filed and the matter is ready for decision.

         ¶2 This case was commenced by claimant after the State Fund asserted a subrogation interest in settlement proceeds obtained by claimant in a medical malpractice action. Documents attached to petitioner's brief in opposition to state fund's motion for protective order (petitioner's brief) show that the State Fund asserted it was entitled to the entire settlement amount remaining after attorney fees and costs were subtracted but would settle for half of that amount. The petitioner requested this Court to find that the State Fund has no right to any portion of the settlement.

         ¶3 In its written response to the petition the State Fund reiterated its position that it had a subrogation interest in the settlement. Thereafter the State Fund expressly "waived" its alleged right and moved to dismiss the petition in its entirety, including the prayer for attorney fees. In a companion order issued today, the Court has granted the State Fund partial summary judgment, holding that the merits of the petition are now moot. (Order Granting Partial Summary Judgment.) However, in that Order I determined that the State Fund is not entitled to dismissal of claimant's request for sanctions, which may include an award of attorney fees.

         ¶4 Claimant has cited deposition testimony indicating that the State Fund's decision to pursue a subrogation interest in the settlement proceeds was not based on any cognizable legal authority. He suggests that the decision was motivated by the desire to maximize State Fund's profits and justify large bonuses and salaries for State Fund. One of the subjects he apparently wishes to pursue in any deposition is Mr. Swanson's "personal knowledge of the State Fund's policies regarding raises and bonuses based upon performance goals of the State Fund." (Petitioner's Brief at 6.)

         ¶5 Sanctions are governed by section 39-71-2914, MCA, which provides:

39-71-2914. Signing of petitions, pleadings, motions, and other papers --requirements -- sanctions. (1) very petition, pleading, motion, or other paper of a party appearing before the workers' compensation court and represented by an attorney must be signed by at least one attorney of record in his individual name. The signer's address also must be stated.
(2) A party who is not represented by an attorney shall sign his petition, pleading, motion, or other paper ...

Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.