United States District Court, D. Montana, Butte Division
In re SPANISH PEAKS HOLDINGS II, LLC, Debtor.
CH SP ACQUISITIONS, LLC; ROSS P. RICHARDSON, Ch. 7 Trustee, Appellees. PINNACLE RESTAURANT AT BIG SKY, LLC; MONTANA OPTICOM, LLC, Appellants, Bankruptcy No. 12-60041
MEMORANDUM AND ORDER
SAM E. HADDON United States District Judge
On November 30, 2006, Citigroup Global Markets Realty Corp. ("CM") loaned Spanish Peaks Holding II, LLC's ("SPHII") predecessor, Spanish Peak Holdings, LLC ("SPH"), $130, 000, 000 secured by a mortgage on real property in Madison and Gallatin Counties, Montana. The mortgage was recorded that same day. The mortgage was later amended and was eventually assigned to CH SP Acquisitions, LLC ("CHSP") on April 19, 2013.
Spanish Peaks Development, LLC ("SPD") and SPH entered into a lease ("2007 Restaurant Lease") for property subject to the mortgage in Madison County, Montana ("the Restaurant Property") on December 14, 2007. On December 12, 2008, SPD assigned the 2007 Restaurant Lease to Pinnacle Restaurant at Big Sky, LLC ("Pinnacle"). An abstract of the 2007 Restaurant Lease giving notice was recorded in Madison County on December 30, 2008. On January 1, 2009, SPH leased other real property subject to the mortgage to Montana Opticom, LLC ("the Telecommunication Property"). The Telecommunication Property Lease was not recorded.
SPH II, Spanish Peaks Lodge, LLC, and the Club at Spanish Peaks, LLC (collectively, the "Debtors"), commenced Chapter 7 proceedings in Delaware. The cases were transferred to Montana in January 2012. Ross P. Richardson was appointed as Chapter 7 Trustee ("Trustee").
In June 2013, Trustee sold the property subject to the original mortgage and the lessee leases to CHSP to satisfy Debtors' debts. CHSP later asked the Bankruptcy Court to determine that the sale to CHSP was free and clear of the 2007 and 2009 leases. The Bankruptcy Court so ruled on March 10, 2014. This appeal followed.
This Court has appellate jurisdiction to review final orders of the Bankruptcy Court under 28 U.S.C. § 158(a).
STANDARD OF REVIEW
The Bankruptcy Court's findings of fact are reviewed for clear error. Its conclusions of law are reviewed de novo. Mixed questions of law and fact are reviewed de novo.
Numerous arguments in favor of and in opposition to the parties' respective positions in this appeal were advanced both in the briefs and during an extended hearing on the merits held June 9, 2015. Nevertheless, resolution of a single issue is dispositive:
Did the Bankruptcy Court err in holding that the sale of debtors' real property in satisfaction of a 2006 mortgage was free and clear of liens grounded in the subordinate ...